Blogger Central, The Student Voice

Real-world learning vs. school grades & credits. No contest.

Jack Hostager is a high school sophomore enrolled in an Eastern Iowa High School. His blog, Straight from the Desk, seeks to add the seldom heard voice of the student. Jack prefers to keep the name of the school he attends private in order to keep the conversation focused on the larger system rather than assuming any of his comments are strictly about his school alone. This week Jack contrasts “real-world” contributions with the consumer mentality of school. 

At the beginning of March, I was lucky enough to spend five days with three friends in Washington, DC at the Coastal America Student Summit on the Oceans and Coasts. In order to go to the conference, we had to select and plan a project to carry out in our community. We decided to build a rain garden around the parking lot of our school to collect runoff and all the noxious oils, roadway salts, & chemicals on the lot so that they will infiltrate the soil and pass through the natural filter of soil instead of flowing into a nearby stream. After we enthusiastically defined our vision, we wrote an action plan, produced a video, and made a poster to “market” the project. Then we met with school and city officials to explain what we wanted to do and make sure the garden would be funded. When we got to the Summit, we met the 70 other attendees from across the continent and learned about the projects they have undertaken. We publicly presented on stage at the Smithsonian Museum of Natural History to a panel of federal officials, then wrote a proclamation to Congress and met with lawmakers on Capitol Hill to discuss environmental issues.

It took a lot to get this project off the ground. We spent many evenings and weekends planning it, then missed two days of school to go on the trip. But our hard work paid off: this was indisputably the best learning experience I have ever had. I learned more than I could have ever learned in a classroom about how the planet works, ways in which humans depend on & impact the ocean, and efforts being undertaken to conserve them. Equally important, I discovered how to work well with others, connect with people, be persuasive, speak in front of an audience, answer questions under pressure, juggle competing priorities, and follow through with a project.

These all sound like skills that every student should have. Yet because I didn’t practice them in a classroom, I was punished by education’s systems of grading for this. When I got back to school, my grades had dropped (some considerably) since I missed a few assignments and a test. It was as if the whole experience meant nothing because I learned the wrong thing. But it would have been irrelevant even if it directly related to what I was studying because I still would have had to make up the work, listen to a lecture, and eventually take a test.

“Apparently my job is to shut up and study hard.”

After returning inspired and ready to change the world only to be thrust back into the invariable cycle of desks, worksheets, textbooks, and lockers, education’s expectation for me hit me painfully hard. I realized that apparently my job is to shut up and study hard.  If I’m so inclined, I can go out for a sport or join a club, but my schoolwork should trump all. I’m not supposed to contribute anything noteworthy to the world, but instead lay low and consume it until after I’ve graduated. Sure, adults applaud when we do something great outside of school. But ultimately school only cares if it meets some curriculum standard that can be measured. Oh, and it has to be the one we are studying right now, and it has to be part of an assignment that’s going in the gradebook. If not, I don’t get credit and therefore it’s a waste of my time.

Only it isn’t.

The obtuse model of education leaves no room for learning beyond school. It makes it very difficult to be a so-called great student and do something meaningful outside of the classroom at the same time. I find this ironic: if education is really preparing us for the real world, then these should be synonyms, not choices. We are a far cry from actualizing the John Dewey quote we all know and love: “Education is not preparation for life; education is life itself.”

Nonetheless, some of us are acting in spite of a system that tells us not to. So imagine how much more we could do if school allowed us to pursue our passions as part of our education instead of repressing them. Imagine how much more excited and motivated students would be if they could engage in real action instead of being told to conform and wait. Imagine if students had to explore and be unique in order to conform.

We refuse to wait to find our place in the world. The question is whether school is going to help us or continue to try to stop us. It shouldn’t take a trip halfway across the country to answer that.

4 thoughts on “Real-world learning vs. school grades & credits. No contest.
  • Casey Vento says:

    I feel the same way, this is great but what always perplexed me is how to change this messed up system to be applicable to the real world beyond cinder block walls.

  • C Santos says:

    As a teacher, I sympathize with your plight and agree with your overall assessment of the Ed system. Unfortunately unless there is a mass protest/revolution it won’t change anytime soon…

  • Peggy Forero says:

    I work in an elementary school and have worked in the high school summer school on Long Island N.Y. I have seen so many kids who can’t relate to what’s being taught, are bored, can’t sit at a desk all day to learn, and whose passions are not allowed to be expressed through that narrow curriculum you talked about. It’s heartbreaking. Maybe you could make starting that education revolution one of your next projects! In N.Y. Many kids and parents refused to take state exams. I think the ball is rolling, and we just need thousands more parents and kids to demand more from the system! Congrats to you on your accomplishments and keep on fighting!

  • @MrBignell says:

    While I admire your passion in giving to your community, Trace, I can also sympathize with your teacher’s expectations. As a teacher, I constantly have various students going on trips, sporting events, etc.. Many of these events are for school, are beneficial, and some even put on by the school. I ask my students one thing: keep yourselves organized so you can submit in any assignments missed. Especially with a planned absence, it’s a true sign of maturity when a student asks what they’ll be missing in the next week, and how they can submit it on time (either before they leave, electronically, or arrange an extension).

    I don’t think you should count this situation as a total loss. Many universities, colleges, etc. look for “experience” in combination of academic performance. In this way, I hope that your devotion pays off.

    In future absences, knowing that education is a system, with both benefits and flaws, you’ll know how to work it and plan for your absence. I understand the frustration, but maybe the students role should be to “become mature citizens, and study hard” — as there’s no need to shut up, as I’ve really enjoyed your thoughts.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>